|
WELCOME
The art market, is the last unregulated frontier of commerce.
Art WatchDog
is here, ready to expose the scammers, thieves and frauds that thrive in the dark, before your hard earned money disappears down that proverbial drain, taking with it the reputations and often the livelihood of many a talented artist.
They're now on notice.
|
Jennie Miller a C & G Staff Writer Southfield, Michigan
A lawsuit has been filed in Oakland County Circuit Court against Park West Galleries Inc., owner Albert Scaglione, gallery director Morris Shapiro and Royal Caribbean Cruises Ltd., with 10 plaintiffs accusing the gallery of fraud.
March 20, 2009
A LORD convicted of knowingly selling a fake LS Lowry-style painting has been jailed for three years.
David Hewett
The order, Daughters of Mary, Mother of Our Savior, and St. Joseph Chapel, Inc., charged that Albany art dealer Mark LaSalle made a false appraisal of a painting, which belonged to the religious orders, breached his contract and warranties, and made false and fraudulent statements to the orders, and that Mark Zaplin worked in concert with Mark LaSalle, and "perpetrated fraud" against the orders.
Samuel Maull, AP New York March 27, 2009
The owner of a now-closed Manhattan art gallery with a star-studded clientele was painted as a thief who stole $88 million from art owners, a bank and investors, including tennis great John McEnroe.
Filed December 9, 2008
French artist Pierre-Auguste Renoir and one of his assis¬tants, Richard Guino, created the eleven sculptures at issue between 1913 and 1917 ("the sculptures"). The sculptures were first published in France no later than 1917 under Pierre-Auguste Renoir's name. There was no pre-1978 publication containing an American-style copyright notice.
Conclusion For the foregoing reasons, we find that Defendants infringed Societe's copyrights in the sculptures. We therefore AFFIRM the district court's grant of summary judgment in favor of Societe on its copyright infringement claim.
AFFIRMED

By Danielle Robert and The Art Newspaper
Rodin, Barye and Maillol are just a few of the French sculptors reproduced by Guy Hain who awaits judgment this month
John Lehmann from the New York Post March 11, 2004
A respected Manhattan art dealer masterminded a multimillion-dollar international art scam in which he bought up works by 19th century French artists, forged them and sold off the fakes through prestigious auction houses, the feds charge.
Dennis Wagner from the The Arizona Republic July 28, 2003
Pierre-Auguste Renoir, the celebrated French Impressionist, once mused, "Why shouldn't art be pretty? There are enough unpleasant things in the world."
Nearly a century later, a bunch of that unpleasantness has exploded in a legal feud over Renoir sculptures at Rima Fine Art on Scottsdale's gallery row.
"Rima Fine Art" and "House of Renoir" not the real deal after all
On June 18 "Rima Fine Art", "House of Renoir", Tracy Penwell and Dror Darel managed to place a TRO (Temporary Restraining Order) on us for publishing information questioning the authenticity of the Renoir Sculptures in their gallery and on their web. Forcing us to remove information from our web.
The information in question is now back and marked
with *.
This restraining order was obtained without us having an opportunity to respond in court. A court date was scheduled for July 3 2003. Documents were to be exchanged between the parties on June 30th and depositions were scheduled for July 1 2003. After the Rima bunch and their attorneys received our documents they withdrew from their attempt to obtain a restraining order against us. In effect admitting that they have no case and that what we have said can not be disputed in court.
|
A letter from the Renoir and Guino family points out that most of the Renoir sculptures at the "Rima Fine Art Gallery" in Scottsdale AZ, owned by Tracy Penwell and run by Dror Darel are FAKE. The original plasters the gallery claims are in their collection are actually at the SUSSE Foundry in Paris click to see document.
Scottsdale
A U.S. District Court jury has ordered a Scottsdale gallery to pay $50,000 in damages for violating 10 copyrights by reproducing a collection of sculptures created by artists Pierre-Auguste Renoir and Richard Guino.
Outcome:Plaintiff's verdict against Dror Darel and Tracy Penwell for $50,000 violating 10 copyrights and against Jean-Emmanuel for $75,000 for violating the same copyrights.
Nadim Samman September 10, 2005
A plan to market thousands of reproductions is revealed in an Arizona courtcase.
Lying, stealing, forging, illegal copying and illegal investment schemes.
Evan Wall Carter also known as Michael Harrison was arrested at 8 a.m. Thursday January 9 2003. This is one con man that is now off the internet due to the efforts of all the people involved.
The police have charged him with 42 counts of FELONY GRAND THEFT.
Standards Australian is seeking industry agreement for a new national code of conduct and on-line register for the art industry to stamp out art forgeries, which cost art buyers millions of dollars. Art fraud has reached epidemic proportions around the world with thousands of people falling victim every year.
Know what you are buying. Read about your field of interest and get acquainted with the prices in auction catalogs and different shops before you start buying.

Alberto Chailosky
I am sure you did not know they were stolen at the time of purchase. Mr. Rosenbaum can be quite slick and deceiving. I need to know if you own one of these pieces. I have NO intention of prosecuting you, or asking for my work back.
Accused of amassing large amounts of money by selling fakes of modern masters on the art market as newly rediscovered works.
It is also alleged that he corrupted valuable art archives - including those at the Tate Gallery and the Victoria and Albert Museum - by forging histories for the works, thereby damaging "British heritage" and potentially ruining the reputations of the artists involved.
In 1985, an art dealer in Missouri purchased a Renoir painting entitled La Loge (also called Au Theatre) for $191,000. He later learned the painting was a fake and was copied from an existing Renoir located in Paris.
The scam is old, but the twist is new: peddling fraudulent art as an investment.
Well at least protect yourself from art fraud. 1. Internet Buying Guide 2. Check Your Collection
|
|